Craig Brewer’s Song Sung Blue is not a biopic about multi-platinum singer-songwriter Neil Diamond. Rather, it is a biopic about a real-life Neil Diamond tribute band that reached improbable success in and around Milwaukee, Wisconsin, in the 1980s and ’90s. The film is based on a 2008 self-financed documentary of the same title by Greg Kohs, a former NFL Films and commercial director who spent a decade working on it. Kohs’s film won the Jury and Audience Awards for Best Documentary at the 2008 Slamdance Film Festival, continued on the festival circuit for a year, and grabbed the attention of some major critics, including Roger Ebert, but afterwards seems to have largely faded from view. Brewer had seen the film at the Memphis Independent Film Festival during its initial festival run, and years later contacted Kohs about turning it into a scripted dramatic film, which, ironically, had been Kohs’s original intention.

One of the reasons Kohs had been unable to turn the story of Mike and Claire Sardina into a dramatic feature was the insistence by various producers that it was too improbable and that no one would believe it. And that is precisely what makes Song Sung Blue such a genuine pleasure—it tells a story that you just simply couldn’t make up. If Rocky (1976) had been about a Neil Diamond tribute band, then it would be Song Sung Blue; it has that same scrappy, refuse-to-die ethos that reminds you of just how resolute the human spirit can be when people are doing something they genuinely love. And what Mike and Claire Sardina love doing is performing Neil Diamond songs.

Mike (Hugh Jackman) is a Vietnam veteran and 20-year recovering alcoholic who makes a living fixing cars and singing, primarily cover tunes (Elvis, Bon Jovi, Don Ho) under the stage name “Lightning.” He is a scruffy, blue-collar guy with a big heart and a generous disposition, which makes him appealing to Claire (Kate Hudson), a single mom with a teenage daughter (Ella Anderson) and adolescent son (Hudson Hensley). Claire also performs cover songs as a kind of second career (she sings and plays keyboards), and when they get together romantically and professionally, they called themselves “Lightning and Thunder” and settle on playing Neil Diamong tunes because Mike looks and sounds like Neil Diamond and—hey—who doesn’t love belting out “Sweet Caroline”? (Well, actually a lot of people, but part of the film’s character derives from Diamond’s unique brand of spirit-stirring contemporary rock, which has often been critically lambasted in ways that completely miss the way his music connects with his audience.) Claire intuitively understands how their peculiar art can stand out from so much cultural clutter when she tells Mike that he doesn’t want to impersonate Diamond, but rather interpret him.

Song Sung Blue follows Mike and Claire through the ups and downs of their unlikely career, which is aided by their agent, who also happens to be Mike’s dentist (Fisher Stevens), a delightfully oddball manager who also drives a tour bus (Jim Belushi), and several session musicians (Michael Imperioli and Mustafa Shakir) who believe enough in Mike and Claire’s chemistry to throw caution to the wind and join the band. They also find crucial support in their blended family, which also includes Mike’s teenage daughter from a previous marriage (King Princess).

There is a genuine, old-school ethos of togetherness and a vibrant work ethic that roots the film’s unlikely story arc in a rich vein of tangible humanity. Jackman and Hudson are both outstanding, especially when an unforeseeable accident turns everything upside down and threatens to derail all of their hard-won success. Brewer—who exploded onto the scene 20 years ago with Hustle & Flow (2005), another underdog story about a very different kind of struggling musician—mines some deep recesses of melodrama when the time comes, but he never milks it or pushes it beyond what the film can bear. There are genuine moments of heartbreak and sorrow and frustration and anger, but by then we have come to love the characters and their hardscrabble existence in a way that allows them to transcend their failures. They aren’t perfect, but they also don’t trip into routine dramatic traps that are often the province of such stories. Song Sung Blue rises and falls, but then rises again in ways that work with an organic chemistry of drama and good humor (Belushi does yeoman work here in a role that easily could have become a silly caricature). And, man, does it have a great soundtrack.

Copyright © 2026 James Kendrick

Thoughts? E-mail James Kendrick

All images copyright © Focus Features