The Girl Can't Help It

Director: Frank Tashlin
Screenplay: Frank Tashlin and Herbert Baker
Stars: Tom Ewell (Tom Miller), Jayne Mansfield (Jerri Jordan), Edmond O’Brien (Marty “Fats” Murdock), Julie London (Self), Ray Anthony (Self), Barry Gordon (Barry the Paperboy), Henry Jones (Mousie), John Emery (Wheeler), Juanita Moore (Hilda)
MPAA Rating: NR
Year of Release: 1956
Country: U.S.
The Girl Can’t Help It Criterion Collection Blu-ray
The Girl Can’t Help It

By any stretch, Frank Tashlin’s The Girl Can’t Help It is a uniquely bizarre film, one that is both a distinct product of its era, but also a strange experiment in melding genres and audience tastes that, at the time, were usually kept separate. At its narrative level, The Girl Can’t Help It is a traditional showbiz comedy-satire in which Tom Miller (Tom Ewell), a theatrical talent agent who has squandered his former success with too much booze, is hired by Marty “Fats” Murdock (Edmond O’Brien), a garrulous just-past-his-prime gangster, to turn his new girlfriend, the voluptuous Jerri Jordan (Jayne Mansfield), into a pop star even though she apparently has no ability to sing. What she does have, though, is Mansfield’s 40-21-35 dimensions, which for a comedy of this sort, is enough justification.

At the same time, though, The Girl Can’t Help is a jukebox musical, sold heavily on the strength of its lineup of musical performers who appear throughout the film as themselves playing in various clubs (the promotional material prominently features the names and likenesses of the musicians, although they still play second-fiddle to Mansfield). Released in 1956, it followed several films, including The Blackboard Jungle (1955) and Teenage Crime Wave (1955), that were explicitly aimed at adolescent audiences and used the new musical form of rock’n’roll in their marketing. Early the next year, enterprising independent producer Sam Katzman churned out Rock Around the Clock (1956), a rock version of the Big Band musicals of the 1940s that heralded a new era in the merging of movies and popular music. That film’s success ensured that a whole slate of similarly themed and titled films would be rushed into production over the next year, mostly from independent producers who were ready and willing to exploit the disreputable new musical form: Shake, Rattle, and Rock! (1956), Rock, Rock, Rock! (1956), and Rock, Pretty Baby (1957), to name a few.

The Girl Can’t Help It stood out from this flourishing new genre, and not just because it failed to include the word “rock” somewhere in the title. Its primary distinction was the fact that, despite prominently featuring musical acts like Little Richard, Fats Domino, The Platters, and Eddie Cochran, all of whom appealed primarily to the teenage market, the film features no teenagers. None. All of the other rock musicals focused on adolescent protagonists with whom their adolescent audiences could identity, but The Girl Can’t Help It exists in some fantastical netherworld populated entirely by adults who spend time in posh nightclubs headlined by musical acts that would never play such venues. In its own weird way, The Girl Can’t Help It attempted to package adolescent taste into a mainstream studio-produced film, underscored by the inclusion of musical acts like Ray Anthony, Abby Lincoln, and Julie London who would appeal primarily to parents. As the reviewer in Variety wrote, “While there are a number of Rock ‘n’ Roll features plying the market, The Girl Can’t Help is the first deluxe version.” The film was shot, after all, by cinematographer Leon Shamroy, who had already earned 12 Oscar nominations and won three (he would go on to win one more, although his work here was overlooked by the Academy).

And, outside of the strange, major studio age-demographic intersection, The Girl Can’t Help It is just an odd film—delightfully so—part of which can be explained by the fact that co-writer/director Frank Tashlin originally worked as an animator whose most famous films were the zany Merrie Melody and Looney Tunes shorts he directed for the Leon Schlesinger unit at Warner Bros. He also worked briefly for Ub Iwerks, Hal Roach, and Walt Disney, and he wrote comic bits for The Marx Brothers, Lucille Ball, and Red Skelton. It should come as no surprise that six of his last seven films were Jerry Lewis comedies—Rock-A-Bye Baby (1958), The Geisha Boy (1959), Cinderfella (1960), It’s Only Money (1962), Who’s Minding the Store? (1963), and The Disorderly Orderly (1964)‚ which partially accounts for his being better known among French cinephiles than Americans (the French film journal Positif dedicated a whole issues to him in 1958, which he was surprised to see on a shelf in a bookstore in Paris and was unable to read because he didn’t know French). Unfortunately, Tashlin’s name has been largely obscured in the history books by the comic actors with whom he collaborated, although Peter Bogdanovich did include an interview with him in his book Who the Devil Made It alongside the likes of Howard Hawks, Alfred Hitchcock, Fritz Lang, and Josef von Sternberg.

The Girl Can’t Help It was originally based on the short story “Do Re Mi” by screenwriter Garson Kanin (Adam’s Rib), which was originally published in The Atlantic magazine in March 1955. But, by the time Tashlin and Herbert Baker, a screen- and songwriter with whom he had previously worked on the Martin-and-Lewis comedy Artists and Models (1955), were through with it, it was so different that Kanin asked for his name to be removed. As an animator and gag writer, Tashlin loved big jokes and borderline-surreal absurdity, which allowed him to often have his cake and eat it, too. In numerous interviews Tashlin noted the humor he found in American male sexuality and the attendant fetishization of female bodies, especially breasts, and when viewed from that perspective, The Girl Can’t Help It is a veritable take-down of female objectification.

Take, for example, the famous scene in which Mansfield, a former Playboy Playmate in her first starring role, walks down the street, catching the eye of every man she passes without ever seeming to notice. The exploitation of Mansfield as an object of the male gaze is played straight—everyone in the audience gets to visually oogle Mansfield in the same way as all the characters on screen—and it is satirized, as Tashlin throws in various cartoonish effects such as the ice-delivery man’s block of ice melting, the milk-delivery man’s bottle of milk boiling over, and one guy’s glasses shattering right on his face, the lenses apparently not strong enough to withstand Mansfield’s sexuality. A similar point could be made with the scene in which Fats first introduces Tom to Jerri, who we see before Tom does standing in a doorway, staring vacantly into space while waiting to be seen. She is thus not just an object, but an object who knows she is an object and purposefully behaves as such, positioning herself for maximum visibility. No surprise, then, that Tom’s primary means of “promoting” her is to take her to various clubs and have her walk to the ladies’ room, thus guaranteeing male visual attention.

The loosening of the industry’s formerly taut Production Code can be charted across virtually every scene in the film, belying all the trouble Howard Hughes had with The Outlaw (1946), a Western that was sold more on Jane Russell’s sex appeal than action, a mere decade earlier. Double entendres fly from all corners, and Tashlin is never above framing Mansfield so that her endowments dominate the frame (to the point that her cleavage could easily be given a separate credit). Tashlin was no stranger to pushing the limits of suggestive humor, as a number of his ideas for Arists and Models were nixed by the Production Code Administration, including naming Jerry Lewis’s character Fullstick. However, because The Girl Can’t Help It is so purposefully cartoonish in both its visual construction and its tonalities, one can imagine the otherwise strict moralists at the PCA giving it a pass because Mansfield’s Jerri is about as real as the animated sexpots in Tex Avery cartoons (which, of course, doesn’t make her any less problematic in terms of female representation, but does speak to our inherit tendency to treat different kinds of images differently in terms of their perceived effect).

Jayne Mansfield is not the film’s only special effect, though. As actor Tom Ewell informs us in the film’s opening prologue, The Girl Can’t Help It “was photographed in the grandeur of CinemaScope,” Fox’s recently patented anamorphic widescreen process, the horizontal dimensions of which he accentuates by snapping his fingers and causing the edges of the frame to open up and reveal more visual space on either side. But, more than that, it was also shot in “gorgeous, lifelike color by DeLuxe,” which we see highlighted as the previously black-and-white image suddenly morphs into the gaudy Technicolor-esque hues of red, blue, and teal, which are anything but “lifelike.” But, they fit The Girl Can’t Help It perfectly, as does the moment when Ewell’s stagy monologue about “the music that expresses the culture, the refinement, and the polite grace of the present day” is suddenly drowned out by a jukebox blaring the raucous sound of Little Richard’s title song, which John Waters would later appropriate for Divine’s Mansfield-esque stroll through the squalor of pre-gentrification Baltimore in his notorious Pink Flamingos (1972). That single image of Tom Ewell on one side, wearing a white-tie tuxedo and speaking without being heard, and the gaudily lit jukebox on the other side blaring rock’n’roll, is singular in its summation of what the film has to offer and how delightfully weird it is in trying to straddle multiple generations, genres, and tones. A real cartoon couldn’t have done better.

The Girl Can’t Help It Criterion Collection Blu-ray

Aspect Ratio2.35:1
  • English Linear PCM 1.0 monaural
  • SubtitlesEnglish
  • Audio commentary by film scholar Toby Miller
  • “The Grandeur of CinemaScope” video essay by David Cairns
  • Archival interview with Jayne Mansfield
  • Archival interview with Little Richard
  • Video interview with filmmaker John Waters
  • Video conversation between WFMU DJs Dave “the Spazz” Abramson and Gaylord Fields
  • Video interview with Mansfield biographer Eve Golden
  • On-set footage
  • Trailer
  • DistributorThe Criterion Collection
    Release DateApril 19, 2022

    It has been 17 years since Fox released its Jayne Mansfield boxset, which included a DVD of The Girl Can’t Help It, so it was high time that the film be given a new transfer. Unfortunately, the transfer we have on Criterion’s Blu-ray, while superior in detail and clarity, is a bit of a disaster when it comes to the color. The image derives from a new scan of the original 35mm camera negative, which was done by Fox with no input (I am assuming) from Criterion. The “lifelike color by DeLuxe” feels deeper and more saturated than the DVD, but the image is notably darker and some of the colors are not nearly as garish (“muted” isn’t exactly the right word, but they definitely don’t stand out quite as much in some scenes). The color grading on the transfer has definitely shifted the overall look of the film, leaning it more toward a darker cyan/blue/teal, which works in some scenes where blues and green dominates, but tends to mute the red end of the spectrum. It is hard to know whether this is closer to the intended look of the film, or if it supposed to be brighter as on the DVD. The image is clean and well preserved, with few if any signs of age or wear. The original monaural soundtrack was transferred from the 35mm monaural soundtrack and is presented in a clean, Linear PCM monaural track. Part of me wishes for an expanded multi-track remix, but the monaural is what audiences originally heard in theaters and it also replicates the way that early rock music was listened to.

    If the presentation is a bit of a disappointment, Criterion’s Blu-ray makes up for it with a stack of supplements, some familiar from previous releases and some new to this edition. From Fox’s 2006 Jayne Mansfield DVD box set, we have an excellent audio commentary by film scholar Toby Miller, who elaborates at length about the film itself, its place in Hollywood film history, and the various social and culture issues surrounding it (particularly female representation). It is a great listen that is deeply informative and will likely help you see the film through renewed eyes. Also illuminating in this regard is “The Grandeur of CinemaScope and Gorgeous Lifelike Color by DeLuxe,” a new 16-minute video essay by film scholar David Cairns that pays particularly close attention to the film’s cinematography, with special emphasis on noted cinematographer Leon Shamroy and color consultant Leonard Doss. There is also a new 30-minute conversation between WFMU DJs Dave “The Spazz” Abramson and Gaylord Fields, who discuss the importance of the film’s music. For those who want to know more about star Jayne Mansfield, there is a 40-minute episode of Karina Longworth’s podcast You Must Remember from 2017 about her and a 14-minute interview with Eve Golden, author of Jayne Mansfield: The Girl Couldn't Help It that focuses on her relationship with the press. From the archive we get a 15-minute interview with Mansfield from a 1957 episode of Tabloid and a 15-minute interview with Little Richard from a 1984 episode of The Merv Griffith Show, as well as a few minutes of on-set footage (no sound). From 2004 we have a video interview with filmmaker John Waters, who waxes rhapsodic (as only he can) about the film—which is one of his favorites—and especially his appreciation of Mansfield as an icon. There is also a trailer for the film and, along with the insert booklet that features a new essay by critic Rachel Syme, there is a separate booklet of excerpts from director Frank Tashlin’s 1952 book How to Create Cartoons with a new introduction by Ethan de Seife, author of Tashlinesque: The Hollywood Comedies of Frank Tashlin.

    Copyright © 2022 James Kendrick

    Thoughts? E-mail James Kendrick

    All images copyright © The Criterion Collection

    Overall Rating: (3)

    James Kendrick

    James Kendrick offers, exclusively on Qnetwork, over 2,500 reviews on a wide range of films. All films have a star rating and you can search in a variety of ways for the type of movie you want. If you're just looking for a good movie, then feel free to browse our library of Movie Reviews.

    © 1998 - 2022 - All logos and trademarks in this site are the property of their respective owner.