Claudine

Director: John Berry
Screenplay: Tina Pine & Lester Pine
Stars: Diahann Carroll (Claudine Price), James Earl Jones (Rupert “Roop” Marshall), Lawrence Hilton-Jacobs (Charles), Tamu Blackwell (Charlene), David Kruger (Paul), Yvette Curtis (Patrice Price), Eric Jones (Francis), Socorro Stephens (Lurlene), Adam Wade (Owen), C. Harrison Avery (Minister), Mordecai Lawner (Process Server), Elisa Loti (Miss Kabak)
MPAA Rating: PG
Year of Release: 1974
Country: U.S.
Claudine Criterion Collection Blu-ray
Claudine

At the time of its release in 1974, Claudine was a rare film that centered on a black female protagonist. As film scholar Donald Bogle points out in his book Toms, Coons, Mulattoes, Mammies, & Bucks: An Interpretive History of Blacks in American Films, “very few films [at that time] attempted to explore a black woman’s tensions or aspirations or examine the dynamics of sexual politics within the black community.” The early ’70s had witnessed an explosion of films featuring black protagonists, many of which were also written and directed by black filmmakers, but these were predominately blaxploitation films, focused on swaggering male protagonists at the center of stories about crime and violence. The few films that did feature a female black protagonist were invariably also blaxploitation films that simple swapped the male protagonist for a female one played by Pam Grier or Tamara Dobson.

Thus, Claudine, despite its seemingly modest story, budget, and scale, was something of a revolutionary film, one that took the basic template of the romantic comedy and used it to explore the lived experiences of a single black mother trying to make it financially, emotionally, and romantically in Harlem. The film deals directly with issues of female sexuality, motherhood, economic disparities and the so-called “welfare state,” and the struggles of being black in the immediate post-Civil Rights era—all topics that were largely left off the Hollywood screen. And, even though television had made some inroads in the 1960s and ’70s with series that featured black protagonists and centered on black lives, they were often either overly caricatured or scrubbed for the comfort of white audiences.

One of those shows was Julia (1968–71), which centered around Diahann Carroll’s titular character, a nurse and widowed mother, making it the first American television series to portray a black female professional as its protagonist. The series, which ran for three seasons, was a source of unending controversy, primarily because critics felt that its depiction of single black motherhood was too neat and unrealistic, which is why the casting of Carroll as the titular character in Claudine, a film that is much more firmly grounded in the realities of a hard-knock life, was so important (she was not the first choice, though, as Diana Sands was originally cast and even began production, but had to drop out due to health problems that led to her death less than a year later). Carroll, who earned an Oscar nomination for her performance, plays Claudine as strong, but vulnerable; smart, but the victim of poor choices in her past; determined, but locked into a meager existence of domestic work and welfare. She is, in short, a portrait of what a lot of black Americans were dealing with and are still dealing with, fighting to survive in a system that feels stacked against them at every turn.

Yet, Claudine is not an emotional downer; rather, it is quite the opposite, which is part of what makes it such an impressive and memorable film. The film’s director, John Berry, was an up-and-coming protégé of Orson Welles’s in the 1940s before he found himself on the wrong side of the Hollywood blacklist in the 1950s for his progressive politics. He had stayed busy during the blacklist years by directing films in Europe and had only recently returned to filmmaking in the U.S. in the mid-1960s with a handful of television episodes and the adventure film Maya (1968). Although his whitness means that he lacks direct experience in the situations depicted in Claudine, he nevertheless brings openness, emotional sensitivity, and a direct focus on the characters. His directorial style is clean and unadorned, which lets the relationships take center stage.

We see this especially in Claudine’s relationship with her children, including her oldest son, Charles (Lawrence Hilton-Jacobs), an 18-year-old flirting with revolutionary politics, and her 16-year-old daughter, Charlene (Tamu Blackwell), who is trying to find her identity and is dangerously close to making the same life-changing choices that Claudine made when she was her age. The scene in which Claudine confronts Charlene after she comes home drunk and having been with a boy, is stark in its emotional bluntness, but also reassuring in the portrait it paints of the connections that can be forged between a concerned parent and a confused adolescent. Especially at a time when single black mothers were being demonized as “welfare queens,” it is a refreshing depiction of genuine parental care in the toughest of times.

Screenwriters Tina Pine and Lester Pine, who were married and had collaborated on episodes for TV series like I Spy, Columbo, and All in the Family, make no bones about the tough realities that Claudine (and so many women like her) face on a daily basis, but at the same time it does not lock her into an unending and inescapable cycle of misery and desperation. Rather, the film presents the good with the bad, suggesting that there is joy to be found in the struggle and that sometimes people can and will do the right thing (the soundtrack, which is filled with songs by Gladys Knight & The Pips, often comments directly on the action playing a kind of Greek chorus reinforcing the film’s emotional shifts).

We see this primarily in Claudine’s budding relationship with Roop (James Earl Jones), a sanitation worker she meets in the gilded white neighborhood in which she works as a housekeeper (the dismissive manner in which the wife who lives there complains on the phone about Claudine being late when she is just in earshot tells us all we need to know about her working situation). Roop is big and burly and open-faced, and when he asks Claudine on a date she initially resists because she has been burned by too many men in the past (she is, after all, a single mother with six kids at the age of 36). Yet, something about him breaks down her defenses and she agrees to the date, which her children, who range in age from 18 to 3, are reluctant to celebrate. They have obviously also been burned by the men in Claudine’s life, but Roop turns out to be different—to an extent.

As embodied by Jones, Roop is full of life and vitality and charm, although we later learn that he is himself a deadbeat dad who doesn’t see his own children and later runs away from those responsibilities. He is, like Claudine, flawed and imperfect, which makes him fully human. He is no knight in shining armor or a Romeo beneath the balcony, but he is a hard-working man who maintains his values and sense of self despite his failings. And, most importantly, we get the feeling that he can be an even better man with Claudine, making their romance the best kind of all: redemptive for both of them, which is why we yearn for them to work it out.

Claudine Criterion Collection Blu-ray

Aspect Ratio1.85:1
Audio
  • English Linear PCM 1.0 monaural
  • SubtitlesEnglish
    Supplements
  • Audio commentary from 2003 by actors Diahann Carroll, James Earl Jones, and Lawrence Hilton-Jacobs; filmmaker George Tillman Jr.; and Dan Pine, son of screenwriters Lester Pine and Tina Pine
  • Video conversation between filmmaker Robert Townsend and programmer Ashley Clark
  • Illustrated audio excerpts from a 1974 AFI Harold Lloyd Master Seminar featuring Carroll
  • Video interview with critic Imogene Sara-Smith about director John Berry
  • Essay by critic Danielle A. Jackson
  • DistributorThe Criterion Collection
    SRP$39.95
    Release DateOctober 13, 2020

    COMMENTS
    The image on Criterion’s Blu-ray of Claudine was transferred in 4K from the original 35mm camera negative by the Twentieth Century Fox Restoration Department. The result is a gorgeous representation of a mid-budget ’70s studio film that retains the rich, textured look of celluloid with a healthy level of grain that looks great in motion. The image has a generally desaturated color palette, with much of the action taking place indoors or a night, and black levels and shadow detail look excellent. There are no signs of age and wear. The original monaural soundtrack was transferred from the 35mm magnetic tracks and sounds excellent. The songs by Gladys Knight & The Pips have decent depth and punch when needed for a mono track, and the dialogue is always clean and clear. In terms of supplements, Criterion has added to what was available on the previously released DVD from 2003. We get the same engaging audio commentary recorded by actors Diahann Carroll, James Earl Jones, and Lawrence Hilton-Jacobs; filmmaker George Tillman Jr.; and Dan Pine, the son of screenwriters Lester Pine and Tina Pine, which recounts all manner of production anecdotes and thoughts on the film’s impact and longevity. New to this disc is a 30-minute video conversation between filmmaker Robert Townsend (Hollywood Shuffle), whose filmmaking career and outlook were greatly affected by Claudine, and film programmer Ashley Clark. It is clearly an interview that was recorded in the age of COVID, as Townsend and Clark are on a video conference call. Also new to this disc is “Uncovering John Berry,” an informative 20-minute interview with film critic Imogene Sara-Smith about the life and career of director John Berry, who has been largely (and unfortunately) forgotten. From the archives, Criterion has unearthed 22 minutes of audio recorded from May 1974 of Diahann Carroll discussing the film’s production and release as part of the American Film Institute’s Harold Lloyd Master Seminar series.

    Copyright © 2020 James Kendrick

    Thoughts? E-mail James Kendrick

    All images copyright © The Criterion Collection

    Overall Rating: (3.5)



    James Kendrick

    James Kendrick offers, exclusively on Qnetwork, over 2,500 reviews on a wide range of films. All films have a star rating and you can search in a variety of ways for the type of movie you want. If you're just looking for a good movie, then feel free to browse our library of Movie Reviews.


    © 1998 - 2020 Qnetwork.com - All logos and trademarks in this site are the property of their respective owner.