A Dry White Season

Director: Euzhan Palcy
Screenplay: Colin Welland and Euzhan Palcy (based on the novel by André P. Brink) )
Stars: Donald Sutherland (Ben du Toit), Janet Suzman (Susan du Toit), Zakes Mokae (Stanley), Jürgen Prochnow (Captain Stolz), Susan Sarandon (Melanie), Marlon Brando (McKenzie), Winston Ntshona (Gordon), Thoko Ntshinga (Emily), Leonard Maguire (Bruwer), Gerard Thoolen (Col. Viljoen), Susannah Harker (Suzette), Andrew Whaley (Chris), Rowen Elmes (Johan)
MPAA Rating: R
Year of Release: 1989
Country: U.S.
A Dry White Season Criterion Collection Blu-ray
A Dry White Season

There is a tendency to think of 1980s cinema as a particularly vacuous period in which hyped high-concept blockbusters completely took over, obliterating the artistic and ideological gains of the previous decade’s more daring filmmakers. And, while it is true that producers and executives did start to pull hard on the reins of overtly political and controversial filmmakers, especially in the wake of the financial and critical disaster that was Michael Cimino’s Heaven’s Gate (1980), the Reagan era is nevertheless quite extraordinary for the number of major films tackling difficult political subjects that played widely in theaters: Roland Joffé’s The Killing Fields (1984), a British production distributed in the U.S. by Warner Bros., dramatized the horrors of Pol Pot’s “Year Zero” cleansing campaign in Cambodia; Oliver Stone’s independently produced Salvador (1986) depicted the political instabilities and violence in El Salvador, while his Oscar-winning Platoon (1986) dared to take on the Vietnam War at ground level; and Richard Attenborough’s Cry Freedom (1987), another British production distributed by Universal, depicted a white South African journalist investigating the death of an anti-apartheid activist while in police custody.

One of the most unique and intriguing of this era’s historical-political films is A Dry White Season, an adaptation of Afrikaner André P. Brink’s 1979 novel about a white South African teacher’s growing awareness of the horrors of apartheid and his commiserate political awakening at the expense of his family and professional security (not surprisingly, the book was banned in South Africa, although Brink managed to distribute it there through underground channels). It was a rare Hollywood production to take on apartheid, and it was also the first Hollywood film of any kind to be directed by a black woman, in this case Euzhan Palcy, who was born in Martinique in the French West Indies. Not being a native of South Africa, she nevertheless immersed herself in research, seeking to create as authentic a portrait as possible of what was happening with the minority white population and its subjugation of black Africans.

Palcy, who was a protégé of François Truffaut’s, had directed only one previous feature, Sugar Cane Alley (Rue cases nègres, 1983), which was set in her native Martinique in the 1930s. Tackling A Dry White Season, which had been kicking around several Hollywood studios for the better part of a decade, was a major undertaking, but she embraced the challenge, casting both major Hollywood actors (Donald Sutherland, Susan Sarandon, and Marlon Brando, who she coaxed out of a 9-year retirement) and native South Africans (Zakes Mokae, Winston Ntshona, Thoko Ntshinga). The result is a fascinating, engrossing account of radical injustice that pulls few punches, but also holds out hope that the world can be made a better place (as it turned out, this was the last Hollywood film about apartheid before legal segregation ended in South Africa in the early 1990s).

The story is set in 1976, the year of the Soweto uprising in which students gathered and protested the use of Afrikaans as the only language of instruction. The film depicts the march in the streets of Soweto and the subsequent massacre in which the police opened fired on the unarmed protestors, killing dozens of men, women, and children. Dozens, if not hundreds, more are swept up by the police, including the son of Gordon (Winston Ntshona), who works as a gardener for Ben du Toit (Donald Sutherland), a secondary teacher who was helping Gordon’s son attend his private school. Ben is a decent, but fundamentally complacent man who genuinely believes that the South African government is fair and just (when Gordon’s son is brutally caned by the police, he is sure that he must have done something to deserve it). Ben begins asking more questions when it is discovered that Gordon’s son died in police custody and his body buried in secret; he begins asking even more questions when Gordon is suddenly arrested and also dies in police custody.

We know the truth because we see Gordon being tortured by the sadistic Captain Stolz (Jürgen Prochnow), so when we see Ben going through official channels like a good citizen, taking at face value that explanations given to him by corrupt officials, we know it is all a ruse. Ben begins to see through it all when he aligns with Stanley (Zakes Mokae), an activist friend of Gordon’s, and Melanie (Susan Sarandon), a British investigative journalist. Soon, he has become dedicated to bringing justice to Gordon and his family, first through a human rights lawyer named McKenzie (Marlon Brando) who knows they have no case, but takes it on anyway if only to demonstrate to Ben just how deeply rotten the system has become. Ben’s dedication to achieving justice eventually costs him his family, as his wife, Susan (Janet Suzman), refuses to join his crusade and instead resents him for the trouble it brings down on them personally and professionally.

In some ways, A Dry White Season wears its agenda a bit too openly on its sleeve, as its depictions of good and evil are so stark in their clarity that they risk becoming caricatures (Prochnow’s Captain Stolz, in particular, is glaringly despicable and apparently incapable of being anything other than a relentless sadist). Yet, the dramatic stakes are such that anything less would risk underselling the poisonous extent of apartheid and how it had turned the very notion of justice in South Africa into a cruel joke. The courtroom drama, which unfolds around the film’s midpoint, is particularly infuriating, as we see McKenzie laying out in clear, indisputable terms how the law was betrayed and still losing in spectacular fashion.

The truth, it turns out, does not matter because the truth threatens the system, and A Dry White Season is at its best in dramatizing in clear, humane terms how such a system oppresses and destroys basic humanity. Ben du Toit is a convenient point of identification for a traditional Hollywood audience who might have been unaware of—or indifferent to—the plight of black Africans living under apartheid (in this regard the film is yet another entry in the long line of Hollywood productions about foreign cultures that requires a white face in the lead, although it makes sense given its dramatic agenda of depicting a political and moral awakening). By the time the film has run its course, there is no question about the brutality of the South African regime and the lengths to which it would go to ensure that the white minority maintained its power. For that reason alone, A Dry White Season is an essential film of its time.

A Dry White Season Criterion Collection Blu-ray

Aspect Ratio1.85:1
AudioEnglish DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 surround
  • Video interview with director Euzhan Palcy by film critic Scott Foundas
  • “Five Scenes” program featuring Palcy
  • Interview from 1989 with actor Donald Sutherland
  • Excerpt from a 1995 interview Palcy conducted with Nelson Mandela
  • Footage of Palcy receiving the highest distinction for foreign dignitaries at the 2017 South African National Orders awards
  • Essay by filmmaker and scholar Jyoti Mistry
  • DistributorThe Criterion Collection
    Release DateDecember 11, 2018

    According to the liner notes, Criterion’s presentation of A Dry White Season derives from a new 4K scan of the original 35mm camera negative that was then given extensive digital restoration. The image looks true to the film’s original look, with a general softness and a lot of grain that looks quite good in motion. Colors aren’t too strong, but I assume that it is in keeping with the intended look of the cinematography. The original stereo soundtrack was remastered from the 35mm magnetic track and digitally restored. It has some good depth to it despite being only two-channel, and Dave Grusin’s musical score is quite effective. There are quite a few supplements, beginning with a new video interview with director Euzhan Palcy conducted by film critic Scott Foundas (35 minutes). It doesn’t quite take the place of an audio commentary, but Palcy packs a lot of good information into her discussion, and Foundas asks good questions about her experience directing the film. Palcy also appears in Five Scenes (30 min.), a featurette in which she discusses how she sought to bring authenticity to five scenes in the film. From the archives we get a five-minute appearance by actor Donald Sutherland on the Today show in conjunction with the film’s release in 1989; an excerpt from a 1995 interview Palcy conducted with South African president Nelson Mandela; and footage of Palcy at the 2017 South African National Orders awards being awarded the highest distinction for foreign dignitaries.

    Copyright © 2018 James Kendrick

    Thoughts? E-mail James Kendrick

    All images copyright © MGM / 20th Century Fox Home Entertainment / The Criterion Collection

    Overall Rating: (3.5)

    James Kendrick

    James Kendrick offers, exclusively on Qnetwork, over 2,500 reviews on a wide range of films. All films have a star rating and you can search in a variety of ways for the type of movie you want. If you're just looking for a good movie, then feel free to browse our library of Movie Reviews.

    © 1998 - 2023 Qnetwork.com - All logos and trademarks in this site are the property of their respective owner.