The Hunger Games: Mockingjay–Part 1

Director: Francis Lawrence
Screenplay: Peter Craig and Danny Strong (adapttion by Suzanne Collin; based on her novel Mockingjay))
Stars: Jennifer Lawrence (Katniss Everdeen), Josh Hutcherson (Peeta Mellark), Liam Hemsworth (Gale Hawthorne), Woody Harrelson (Haymitch Abernathy), Donald Sutherland (President Snow), Philip Seymour Hoffman (Plutarch Heavensbee), Julianne Moore (President Alma Coin), Willow Shields (Primrose Everdeen), Sam Claflin (Finnick Odair), Elizabeth Banks (Effie Trinket), Mahershala Ali (Boggs), Jena Malone (Johanna Mason), Jeffrey Wright (Beetee), Paula Malcomson (Katniss’ Mother), Stanley Tucci (Caesar Flickerman)
MPAA Rating: PG-13
Year of Release: 2014
Country: U.S.
The Hunger Games: Complete 4-Film Collection Blu-ray + Digital HD
The Hunger Games: Mockingjay–Part 1If The Hunger Games: Mockingjay–Part 1, the third entry in the hugely popular young adult dystopian series, has anything going for it, it is that it is different. While Catching Fire (2013), the sequel to The Hunger Games (2012), spent the majority of its running time playing out variations on what we had seen in the first film, Mockingjay boldly steps out into entirely new territory, leaving behind the duel-to-the-deaths scenario of the previous entries in favor of a politically weighted, possibly self-reflexive narrative about growing social revolution and raging propaganda wars—pretty heady stuff for a guaranteed blockbuster. That, of course, is also the film’s downfall. As the Part 1 in the title suggests, this film is a whole lot of set-up for what we imagine will be payoff in Part 2, which doesn’t necessarily make it any easier to get through.

Once again set several hundred years in the future in Panem, a fascistic replacement for the United States in which 12 walled-off districts serve the rich and powerful elite living in the technologically advanced Capitol, Mockingjay–Part 1 picks up right where Catching Fire left off, with the teenage heroine Katniss Everdeen (Jennifer Lawrence), having survived another round of the deadly Hunger Games, in the care of an underground revolutionary group headed by President Alma Coin (Julianne Moore) and Plutarch Heavensbee (Philip Seymour Hoffman), a clever propagandist who had been masquerading as the new games master. Katniss is joined by Gale Hawthorne (Liam Hemsworth), her hunky childhood friend from District 12, which has been utterly decimated by the Capitol’s forces in retaliation for joining the revolution against them.

However, Peeta Mellark (Josh Hutcherson), Katniss’s would-be boyfriend who also survived two Hunger Games by her side, has been taken captive by the Capitol, as have several other characters we met in Catching Fire, including Finnick Odair (Sam Claflin) and Joanna Mason (Jena Malone). The devious President Snow (Donald Sutherland), who we first see being shaved and accidentally nicked like Al Capone in Brian De Palma’s The Untouchables (1987), is using Peeta for his own propagandistic purposes, putting him on air in forced interviews with the officious celebrity hound Caesar Flickerman (Stanley Tucci) to argue that another revolution can only hurt more than it can help (we should remember, of course, that the Hunger Games exist only because of a failed revolution against the Capitol by several districts 75 years earlier).

Plutarch is convinced that Katniss—the “mockingjay” of the title—is the key to the revolution, although President Coin is skeptical. She doesn’t think that Katniss, who is still a teenager, after all (even if Jennifer Lawrence no longer looks like one), doesn’t have the revolutionary fire to inspire the masses to revolt. Katniss is unwilling to get involved until she learns about Peeta’s predicament, at which time she agrees to be the face of the revolution as long as President Coin promises to rescue him at the earliest possible opportunity, a neat echo of Katniss’s original sacrifice of herself as “tribute” for District 12 to save her sister’s life.

However, even though Katniss is still willing to put herself and her life on the line to save others, she has never felt so much like a pawn before, which saps the film of the energy that made the previous entries work. Watching her consent to being as a propaganda tool—a revolution’s mascot—just doesn’t have the same dramatic urgency as agreeing to possibly die a terrible death so that her sister may live, and the fact that one of the film’s biggest dramatic moments involves her delivering an angry diatribe into a camera lens is telling. Her character has never been less interesting or dramatically central, which is a shame because she should be, as the narrative arc would suggest, fully coming into her own.

It doesn’t help, either, that the film is so intently dour-looking, with all the characters wearing matching gray jumpsuits and spending most of their time underground debating propaganda tactics. We get a few big action setpieces, including a group of lumberjacks revolting against Capitol storm troopers and another group bum-rushing a hydroelectric dam in order to destroy it, that take us out from the ground for a breath of air, but much of the film feels kind of suffocating. It’s enough to make one long for those awful Victorian-meets-’80s-New-Wave fashions popular in the Capitol, which make no appearance here outside of Caesar Flickman’s purple-haired TV appearances.

Because Mockingjay–Part 1 is almost all set-up, the sense of dramatic urgency is overly stretched, as we sense returning director Francis Lawrence and screenwriters Peter Craig and Danny Strong (working from an adaptation by Suzanne Collins of her own novel) doing everything they can to draw out the plot threads to fill two feature films instead of one (this is now the de facto approach to final installments of successful franchises, following in the wake of Harry Potter and Twilight, not to mention Peter Jackson’s epic undertaking of turning The Hobbit into three gargantuan films). And, while isolated moments work with the intended emotional impact (mostly thanks to fine work by the impressive cast), as a whole the film feels too heavy and deliberate, with all its energy going toward setting up expectations and later payoffs, but without the kind of internal dynamics that make it worth the wait.

The Hunger Games Complete 4-Film Collection
The Hunger Games: Mockingjay–Part 1 is available as part of “The Hunger Games Complete 4-Film Collection” boxset, which also includes The Hunger Games (2012), Catching Fire (2013), and Mockingjay—Part 2 (2015). All four films are also available on Blu-ray and DVD separately.
Aspect Ratio2.40:1
Audio
  • English Dolby Atmos
  • DTS HeadphoneX
  • English Dolby Digital 2.0 surround
  • Spanish Dolby Digital 5.1 surround
  • SubtitlesEnglish, Spanish
    SupplementsThe Hunger Games

    On Separate Blu-ray Disc:

  • The World is Watching: Making The Hunger Games making-of documentary
  • “Game Maker: Suzanne Collins and The Hunger Games Phenomenon” featurette
  • “Letters from the Rose Garden” featurette
  • “Controlling the Games” featurette
  • “A Conversation with Gary Ross and Elvis Mitchell” featurette
  • “Preparing for the Games: A Director’s Process” featurette
  • “Propaganda Film” featurette
  • Theatrical trailers
  • Poster gallery
  • Photo gallery.

    On Complete 4-Disc Collection Bonus Disc:

  • The World is Watching: Making The Hunger Games documentary
  • “Game Maker: Suzanne Collins and The Hunger Games Phenomenon” featurette
  • “Letters from the Rose Garden” featurette
  • “Controlling the Games” featurette
  • “A Conversation with Gary Ross and Elvis Mitchell” featurette
  • “Preparing for the Games: A Director’s Process” featurette
  • “Propaganda Film” featurette
  • “Stories from the Tributes” featurette
  • “Casting the Tributes” featurette
  • “Tribute Video Diaries” featurette
  • “Photo Album” featurette
  • “Stunts of The Hunger Games” featurette
  • “Capitol Couture: The Styles of Panem” featurette
  • “Weapons of the Arena” featurette
  • “Effected: The Visual Artwork of The Hunger Games” featurette
  • “Feast and Famine: Creating the Food for The Hunger Games” featurette
  • “On the Black Carpet: The Hunger GamesPremiere” featurette
  • 12 deleted scenes
  • Theatrical trailers
  • Tribute biographies
  • Poster gallery
  • Photo gallery

    The Hunger Games: Catching Fire

    On Blu-ray Disc:

  • Audio commentary by director Francis Lawrence and producer Nina Jacobson.
  • Surviving the Game: Making The Hunger Games: Catching Fire making-of documentary
  • Deleted scenes

    On Complete 4-Disc Collection Bonus Disc:

  • “The Alliance: Returning Cast” featurette
  • “Friend or Foe: New Cast” featurette
  • “One Vision: A Faithful Adaptation” featurette
  • “The Look of The Hunger Games: Catching Fire” featurette
  • “The Quarter Quell Cast” featurette
  • “Bringing Panem to Life” featurette
  • “Taking Aim: Stunts and Weapons” featurette
  • “The Quell: On Location in Hawaii” featurette
  • “Battling the Clock Arena” featurette
  • “Capitol Cuisine” featurette
  • “Inside District 12: The Hob” featurette
  • Deleted scene
  • Coldplay “Atlas” music video

    The Hunger Games: Mockingjay–Part 1

    On Blu-ray Disc

  • Audio commentary by director Francis Lawrence and producer Nina Jacobson
  • “Hope and Rebellion: Continuing the Saga” featurette
  • “Designing Dystopia: Visual Aesthetic” featurette
  • “Rebels and Warriors: The Cast” featurette
  • “Fusing Form and Function: Costume, Make-Up and Hair” featurette
  • “Fighting the System: Shooting on Location” featurette
  • “D13: Rebellion Tactics: Stunts and Special Effects” featurette
  • “Perfecting Panem: The Post-Production Process” featurette
  • “Straight from the Heart: A Tribute to Philip Seymour Hoffman” featurette
  • “Songs of Rebellion: Lorde on Creating the Soundtrack” featurette
  • Deleted scenes
  • Lorde “Yellow Flicker Beat” music video

    On Complete 4-Disc Collection Bonus Disc:

  • “Rubble and Ashes” featurette
  • “Utilitarian Chic” featurette
  • “The Propos Team” featurette
  • “Combat Zone” featurette
  • “Katniss Propo Video” featurette
  • “Picturing Panem” photo gallery

    The Hunger Games: Mockingjay–Part 2

    On Blu-ray Disc:

  • Audio Commentary by director Francis Lawrence and producer Nina Jacobson
  • “Walking Through Fire: Concluding the Saga” featurette
  • “Real or Not Real: Visual Design” featurette
  • “High-Value Targets: The Acting Ensemble” featurette
  • “From Head to Toe: Costume, Make-up & Hair” featurette
  • “Navigating the Minefield: Production in Atlanta, Paris & Berlin” featurette
  • “Collateral Damage: Stunts, Special Effects & Weapons” featurette
  • “Tightening the Noose: The Post-Production Process” featurette
  • “A Different World: Reflections” featurette
  • The Hunger Games: A Photographic Journey” featurette
  • “Cinna’s Sketchbook: Secrets of the Mockingjay Armor” featurette
  • “Panem on Display: The Hunger Games: The Exhibition” featurette
  • “Jet to the Set” TV special
  • DistributorLionsgate
    SRP$64.97 (boxset)
    Release DateMarch 22, 2016

    VIDEO & AUDIO
    The first three films in the “Complete 4-Film Collection” Blu-ray boxset are simply repackaging of the previously existing discs, which have already been thoroughly reviewed, so I will limit this discussion to the one new disc in the set, Mockingjay–Part 2. Unlike its immediate predecessor, Part 2 is a much more open film in terms of location (Part 1 took place primarily underground and at night, which made it the darkest and moodiest of the four films). Part 2 has action that takes place all over—from the ashen, bombed-out streets of the Capitol, to the snow-covered Presidential Mansion and its golden-hued interiors, to the verdant forests of District 12. The 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer handles all of the visuals extremely well, with plenty of detail and contrast. The film was shot digitally on the Arri Alexa, so it definitely has a hard-edged look to it, but it is in keeping with the overall aesthetic of last two films in the series (The Hunger Games and Catching Fire were both shot on 35mm celluloid, which gives them a slightly different look from the two Mockingjay films). Black levels and shadow detail are good, which benefit those creepy scenes down in the Capitol sewer, although at times the frame is a bit too dark and murky. As with the Blu-ray for Part 1, Mockingjay–Part 2 includes a stellar Dolby Atmos surround soundtrack (although it does not have the DTS HeadphoneX track). The film’s action sequences are fully immersive, with bullets and debris whizzing by you from all directions, and the explosions have a chair-rattling thunder to them. The soundtrack is also excellent in the quieter, more discreet moments, such as the suspenseful build-up to the action in the sewer. All in all, an excellent technical presentation.
    SUPPLEMENTS
    Where, oh where, to begin? Let’s just say that the six-disc “Complete 4-Film Collection” Blu-ray boxset has enough supplementary material to keep diehard Hunger Games fans busy (the press release notes that there are more than 14 hours of supplements included, a good chunk of which is new to this release). Since the Hunger Games, Catching Fire, and Mockingjay–Part 1 discs are all repackaged from their initial releases, they also include all of the original supplements (The Hunger Games actually has a separate Blu-ray disc with all of its supplements, while the next two films have the movie and supplements sharing a single disc). The boxset also includes the newly released Mockingjay–Part 2 and all of its supplements, as well as a separate “Bonus Features” disc of supplements that, somewhat confusingly, duplicates some material from the original releases in addition to adding a bunch of new stuff. To keep this review manageable, I will be focusing only on the supplements on the Mockingjay–Part 2 disc and the new material on the “Bonus Features” disc.

    As with Catching Fire and Mockingjay–Part 1, Mockingjay–Part 2 includes an informative audio commentary by director Francis Lawrence and producer Nina Jacobson, who once again talk through the enormity of the production process and how the film came together. Their discussion is lively and engaging and packed with detail that fans of the series will appreciate.

    Also in keeping with the previous Hunger Games discs, this one has a massive making-of documentary. Under the title Pawns No More: The Making of The Hunger Games: Mockingjay–Part 2, it is composed of eight separate featurettes, which together run nearly two and a half hours. All of the featurettes include extensive behind-the-scenes footage and interviews with almost every major figure from the cast and crew. “Walking Through Fire: Concluding the Saga” focuses on the film’s narrative and how the final installment draws together all of the series’ pertinent themes; “Real or Not Real” focuses on the film’s visual design, beginning with the actual design process and anaimatics and then how the world of the film was brought to life in terms of physical locations, created sets, and practical and digital effects; “High-Value Targets” looks at the always impressive cast assembled for the film, while “From Head to Toe” shows us how they were made up into their unique characters through make-up and costuming; “Navigating the Minefield” explores the extensive physical location work (usually augmented with huge blue and green screens) in and around Atlanta, Paris (which provided both a chateau and housing projects), and Berlin (which provided abandoned military barracks that were turned into the bombed-out Capitol); “Collateral Damage” gives us a behind-the-scenes look at the film’s stunts and special effects; “Tightening the Noose” surveys the extensive post-production process; and, finally, “A Different World” offers reflections on the series and its popularity and impact.

    The Hunger Games: A Photographic Journey” is a fascinating interview with on-set photographer Murray Close, whose career began with Stanley Kubrick’s The Shining (1980). He talks about what it’s like working as a photographer on the sets of some of Hollywood’s biggest films (in addition to all of the Hunger Games films, he has worked on Tim Burton’s Batman, several Spielberg films including Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade and Jurassic Park, and several entries in the X-Men and Harry Potter franchises), as well as the differences between film and digital and how he works with the film’s cinematographer to capture both publicity stills and behind-the-scenes images. “Cinna’s Sketchbook: Secrets of the Mockingjay Armor” is an interview with costume designers Bart Mueller and Kurt Swanson about the design book, briefly glimpsed in the movie, that Cinna created for Katniss’s Mockingjay armor and their work on that costume, while “Panem on Display: The Hunger Games: The Exhibition” is a very brief look at the elaborate, multimedia Hunger Games exhibition that opened in 2015 at San Francisco’s Palace of the Fine Arts and the reaction of the film’s cast and crew to experiencing it. And, finally, the disc includes Jet to the Set, a 41-minute television special that aired on CBS prior to the film’s release. Hosted with much fanfare by Entertainment Tonight’s Carly Steel and Hot in Hollywood’s Laurie Feltheimer, it is a kind of behind-the-scenes travelogue that takes you to the film’s primary locations throughout Atlanta, including The Victor’s Training Center, President Snow’s Mansion, and the 75th Hunger Games Cornucopia, as well as the various places throughout the city where the stars dined and shopped while they weren’t working on the film.

    Now, on to the “Bonus Features” disc, which houses several hours worth of new supplementary material covering various aspects of the first three films in the series. The vast majority of this material is new to the boxset, although some of it is repeated from earlier Blu-ray releases. From the list above, you can see that there is a lot of stuff here, so I will restrict myself to hitting a few of the highlights of what is new and notable for each film.

    For The Hunger Games, “Tribute Video Diaries” is an interesting 17-minute featurette in which seven of the young actors who played tributes in the film recorded video diaries of their experiences during the promotional push between the time when they wrapped filming and the movie’s premiere, while “Stunts of The Hunger Games” shows both rehearsals and behind-the-scenes footage during some of the bigger stunt sequences. And, for fans of Victorian Era-meets-’80s New Wave, there is the 18-minute featurette “Capitol Couture: The Styles of Panem,” which gives a fairly in-depth look at the film’s radical costume designs for the Capital denizens. There are also new featurettes about the weapons in the film, the design of the food we see the characters eating on screen, and visual effects—pretty much every facet of the film’s production is covered in some form or fashion. Probably the biggest new inclusion here, though, are 12 never-before-seen deleted scenes, which together run about 21 minutes. Most of these are direct extensions of scenes already in the film (for example, we see exactly what nightmare Prim was waking from at the beginning) or longer versions of existing scenes, which suggests that most of the footage was cut to trim the running time and help pacing, rather than discard subplots.

    There are also quite a few new supplements for Catching Fire, several of which are definitely worth watching, although most of them are pretty short and don’t go much beneath the surface (remember that there is a 2+-hour making of documentary on the main disc, so that’s not much of a criticism). Of particular interest is the 13-minute featurette “One Vision: A Faithful Adaptation,” in which director Francis Lawrence, producers Nina Jacobson and John Kilik, Scholastic publisher David Levithan, and members of the cast, discuss how hard they worked to stay true to Suzanne Collins’s novel in their adaptation (interestingly, none of the actual screenwriters are interviewed ...). If you combine the 3-minute “The Look of The Hunger Games: Catching Fire” and the 6-minute “Bringing Panem to Life” featurettes, you will have a pretty good exploration of the how the film’s look was put together via costume and production design and visual effects. There is also a never-before-seen deleted scene, but given that it is less than 40 seconds long and never made it past the greenscreen stage, there isn’t much to see there. Fans of Coldplay will appreciate the inclusion of their “Atlas” music video, though.

    And, finally, we arrive at the new material for Mockingjay–Part 1, which is the lightest of the three. There are a handful of new featurettes, including “Utilitarian Chic,” a good 14-minute look the film’s production design and special effects, and “Combat Zone,” a 12-minute featurette that explores the larger war that becomes the subject of the final two films in the series.

    Copyright ©2016 James Kendrick

    Thoughts? E-mail James Kendrick

    All images copyright © Lionsgate

    Overall Rating: (2)




    James Kendrick

    James Kendrick offers, exclusively on Qnetwork, over 2,500 reviews on a wide range of films. All films have a star rating and you can search in a variety of ways for the type of movie you want. If you're just looking for a good movie, then feel free to browse our library of Movie Reviews.


    © 1998 - 2024 Qnetwork.com - All logos and trademarks in this site are the property of their respective owner.